Enter "Black Swan".
I had been looking forward to this movie for some time now, ever since I heard of its release. The subject matter seemed thoroughly dense and enjoyable, and the story itself would be nothing short of thought provoking, as is Mr. Aronofsky's way. I treated myself to a movie this afternoon of Christmas Eve. I went, by myself out to the nearby theatre and sat myself down in a nearly empty room.
While I won't bore you with a plot synopsis, I will try and give you some what of a framework so you know what it is I'm talking about.
In "Black Swan", the main character Nina is a talented ballet dancer. For years she has be aching to be the lead in a production. She gets her break when the former prima ballerina retires. She is cast as the White Swan and as the Black Swan in an avante garde production of Swan Lake. As the movie progresses and the stress involved with mastering the role and getting in touch with herself takes its toll. She begins to hallucinate, and feels as though she is being tricked by the new dancer, Lily (played by Mila Kunis).
The movie itself was unique, in that it wasn't a moral tale with a happy ending. It was intense, bleak and ruthless. Aronofsky is known for making very dark movies that really test the limits of human emotion and endurance. What was really spectacular about "Black Swan" was the way it reminded me of a 1998 movie from Japan called "Perfect Blue". In "Perfect Blue" we are introduced to the character Mima (coincidence?). She is part of a girl group called "CHAM", but she has her sights set on acting. She is given an opportunity to act, but like "Black Swan" this opportunity is fraught with emotional turmoil. She begins to hallucinate that she is being followed by her pop idol self.
While there are many comparisons to be made, it's worth seeing both movies. They show different sides of the fame monster and it's really chilling to think about what actors and actresses have to deal with in order to be famous. It's no wonder that we lose so many of them to addictions or mental disorders. They are constantly pushed and pulled, kneaded like dough. Eventually the dough breaks down and won't hold any shape any longer.
I would like to sit down with a group of like-minded individuals and watch both "Black Swan" and "Perfect Blue". In fact after a little bit more digging I've learned that Darren Aronofsky actually owns the rights to "Perfect Blue" which he bought for a song. He replicated one of the scenes in a previous movie "Requiem for a dream", seen below.
So the fact that "Black Swan" and "Perfect Blue" share so many similarities may be more than just coincidence. I don't find that this detracts from "Black Swan" in any measurable way. I'm of the thinking that if you get a remake of something and it's as good, or better than you've been treated to something special twice.
Is imitation flattery, or simply lazy?
